The Last Friday

The Last Friday is a poetry editing group. Once a month, we post a poem and then offer feedback to the other poems on the Forum. We're a friendly but honest group. We value each other deeply and desire for every poet to be published or become famous.


    Does the first strophe satisfy as an introduction to the poem

    Share

    Dennis 20
    Guest

    Does the first strophe satisfy as an introduction to the poem

    Post  Dennis 20 on Fri Mar 25, 2016 8:36 pm

    Catching Sight of the Wind


    There is a funnel view of the sky
    from the canyon floor.  Eagles soar
    in the clouds like planes.
     
    But a vista view from the canyon rim
    opens horizons in all directions
    like a book with spine splayed open.
     
    Great spans of eagle wings show
    smooth feathers and majestic heads
    that pilot them like fighter jets.
     
    As ghosts, they rise and fall on updrafts,
    emit their eerie squalls, and
    use their tails as rudders.
     
    After hours of watching the freedom
    of lift and dive and soar
    the wind takes on the shape of wings.
    avatar
    tsukany

    Posts : 592
    Join date : 2011-05-21

    Nice image

    Post  tsukany on Sat Mar 26, 2016 7:48 am

    Dennis

    I would challenge the easy simile of stanza one.  What else soars but planes?  The "funnel" to me to storm the first read, but I like the tension it brings.

    I would move stanza two to end the poem.  The comparing of funnel and book is a nice movement.

    Stanza three introduces a new metaphor (since planes could be changed from stanza one).  I really think "book" imagery might be stronger.  Then spans might become "splines"  making a verb of a noun.  (But we all know how I like to complicate things unnecessarily)

    I think that "tails as rudders" is too "factual" and it also leads me to boats . . . funnels, planes, books, jets, ghosts, boats, (last stanza moves from concrete object 'eagles' to invisible winds 'taking shape') as a return to the title.

    Hope that is health food for thought.

    Dennis 20
    Guest

    tuning out the wind noise

    Post  Dennis 20 on Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:52 am

    Catching Sight of the Wind


    There is a funnel view of the sky
    from the canyon floor.  From here
    eagles look like hummingbirds,
     
    but their spans of long,strong wings
    show smooth feathers that lift
    on open air without words.
     
    As ghosts, they rise and fall on updrafts,
    emit their eerie squalls, and
    peruse distant shifting shapes.
     
    After hours of watching the freedom
    of lift and dive and soar
    the wind takes on the shape of wings.
     
    This vista view from the canyon rim
    opens horizons in all directions
    like a book with spine splayed.

    Dewell H. Byrd

    Posts : 356
    Join date : 2012-01-05
    Age : 87
    Location : Central Point, OR

    CATCHING SIGHT OF THE WIND

    Post  Dewell H. Byrd on Sun Mar 27, 2016 3:31 pm

    Dennis,... I'm glad to see the planes disappear (gliders soar... do planes?).  I'm OK with either ending but the revised version is definitely tighter.  Splayed... what a fine image for this poem.  Ghosts bothers me unless it is a shortened simile of some kind.  Not sure about the rudder thing but I have no option to offer...Are vistas and views too similar for this poem?  Nice poem.  Good work.  Dewell

    Pat

    Posts : 630
    Join date : 2011-09-12

    I like the changes.

    Post  Pat on Sun Mar 27, 2016 9:36 pm

    I like that you connected canyon floor with what you are seeing:  the transitional phrase helps smooth it up:  from here.  I'd drop their  in Stanza 2 and 3.  I am clear they are eagles.  Just weeding the second poem.  Last stanza:  This or The?  The second poem keeps me focused, not scattered. Good revision.  Good poem.
    avatar
    Karen

    Posts : 287
    Join date : 2014-10-25
    Age : 64
    Location : North Little Rock

    Re: Does the first strophe satisfy as an introduction to the poem

    Post  Karen on Mon Mar 28, 2016 7:41 pm

    I too like the revision.  I agree with Todd about strengthening the "book" imagery.  Did I dream a suggestion of Hemingways for hummingbirds or am I just not able to see that post on this screen?  I like that.  The ghosts bugged me.  These ancient scholars rise and fall on updrafts ... just trying stuff out here.  Along with Dewell, I'm dissatisfied with vista view, but only have criticism, not solution.

    This poem is so very close to confessing its secret.  Keep after it.  It's a good piece.

    Dennis 20
    Guest

    All the help you give is needed

    Post  Dennis 20 on Wed Mar 30, 2016 11:42 am

    Thanks to all.  Karen, I like your suggestion of Hemmingways.  I think I will use that. Is our group great, or what?
    avatar
    Karen

    Posts : 287
    Join date : 2014-10-25
    Age : 64
    Location : North Little Rock

    Re: Does the first strophe satisfy as an introduction to the poem

    Post  Karen on Wed Mar 30, 2016 12:20 pm

    I could have sworn Todd suggested it.  Perhaps it was the psychic forum.  Yikes.

    Sponsored content

    Re: Does the first strophe satisfy as an introduction to the poem

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Thu Jun 21, 2018 3:22 am